I’ll just say it, and that includes the part of the industry I work in: AI visibility tools are kind of a race to the bottom. I don’t think plain tracking holds up long term. I think everybody’s past visibility now. It’s more about what you do with it.
Pretty much every peer I’ve talked to since BrightonSEO lands in the same spot. Tracking and reporting are table stakes. The execution part is where it’s at.
It’s already a commodity
One directory counts over 200 tools in the AI SEO category. There are hundreds of tools doing this, and a bunch of them are free now. Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools both report on AI features, GA4 can pull out AI referrals, and lots of vendors give away one-off graders. Look at where the paid tools start:
There’s no moat in features
People are cloning pretty big software products with AI coding tools now. If that’s possible, a prompt tracker isn’t a defensible product. Anybody can code up a tool set and customize it to their own use case.
So tool companies whose edge is the dashboard end up on a hamster wheel, constantly shipping new stuff to stay different while everyone else copies it. I think a lot of them will end up building services arms too. The other option is to scale the software and build a giant customer success team, because otherwise customers struggle and leave bad reviews. And in this day and age (especially in AI search) bad reviews are a visibility problem too.
Customers need a lot of hand-holding
This lines up with what I see with clients. You show someone a powerful AI visibility tool and they almost always need help using it. In the best case it’s “done with you.” Most of the time it’s “done for you.” Getting the data isn’t the hard part. Knowing what to do with it is.
That’s the part I care about. Turning the visibility gaps into an actual strategy, creating the right kind of content, then getting it out to owned and earned places (the recommendable stuff). And then testing. Try something on one client, learn from it, try it on another, and keep what actually works. I went deeper on that loop in tracking AI search isn’t a strategy.
If you’re shopping for a tracker
Start with the free stuff before you pay for anything. When you do pay, pay for the prompts and engines you’ll actually act on, not the biggest prompt count. And if you’re spending more on the dashboard than on the work, I’d flip that.
Have the data but not the plan? See our services or get in touch.
Leave a Reply